The TPO wants segment-wise profit and loss accounts for my AE and non-AE business and I cannot produce them. He has levied 2 per cent of the transaction value under s.271G. Can I resist it?
Yes, where the failure is backed by a reasonable cause, because s.273B applies to s.271G. The Tribunal upheld the deletion of a Rs 56,72,162 penalty on a diamond trader who had furnished entity-level margins but could not split AE from non-AE segments, holding that in a trade where rough and polished diamonds move in mixed lots it is practically impossible to trace which rough stone became which polished stone, and that the assessee had substantially complied to the extent the trade allowed.
Decided by the ITAT (Mahavir Singh, Judicial Member and Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member (Mumbai Benches 'K')) on 2018-08-02, reported as IT(TP)A No.2142/Mum/2017 (AY 2011-12). It bears on section 271G, section 92D, section 92D(3), section 273B, section 92CA, section 92CA(3), section 92C(1), section Rule 10D, section Rule 10D(1) of the Income Tax Act 1961, in Penalty and Evidence & Burden of Proof matters.
Section 271G is the penalty the TPO actually levies, and at 2 per cent of the value of the international transaction for EACH failure it is often larger than the adjustment. The defence here is not that the documents were unnecessary but that s.273B removes the penalty where reasonable cause is proved, and that the TPO who cannot get segmentals has other routes to the arm's length price — comparing realisations on export sales to AEs and non-AEs for stones of similar size, quality and weight, or calling for the AEs' own profit and loss accounts and balance sheets to see whether profits were diverted. The Tribunal also treated it as telling that the TPO made no adjustment at all, and that no adjustment had been proposed in the preceding year. The reasoning is written for the diamond trade but the structure travels: identify precisely why the split cannot be produced, show what you did produce, and show the alternative benchmark the TPO could have used.
Binding on the AO and CIT(A) within the Tribunal's jurisdiction. Persuasive elsewhere.
Read aloud by your device. Press again to stop.
For AY 2011-12 the assessee, a diamond firm operating from the Bharat Diamond Bourse, had a turnover of Rs 636.14 crores of which export sales were Rs 238.35 crores; sales to associated enterprises were Rs 28.3 crores, about 12 per cent of exports. Its transfer pricing study used TNMM with operating profit on operating cost as the profit level indicator, and compared its entity-level margin of 14.72 per cent with a comparables' margin of 9.55 per cent. Those entity-level margins combined AE and non-AE transactions. The TPO called for segmental profitability separately for the AE and non-AE segments under s.92D(3), relying on sub-clauses (d), (g) and (h) of Rule 10D(1). The assessee did not furnish the split. The TPO recorded that the details had not been filed within thirty days or at any time afterwards, that they were essential for benchmarking, that no alternative method had been offered, and that in their absence he was forced to accept the transactions as at arm's length after initiating penalty proceedings; he levied Rs 56,72,162, being 2 per cent of the AE transaction value. The CIT(A)-55, Mumbai deleted the penalty by order dated 30 November 2016. The Revenue appealed, arguing among other things that under TNMM the profit of the international transaction itself had to be furnished and that the CIT(A) had given no finding on how clauses (d), (g), (h) and (m) of Rule 10D(1) had been complied with.
The Revenue's appeal was dismissed and the deletion of the penalty upheld. Following the co-ordinate Bench in ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd. on materially identical facts, the failure to furnish AE and non-AE segmental accounts in the diamond manufacturing and trading trade was held to be backed by a reasonable cause within s.273B, the assessee having substantially complied to the extent practically possible.
The reasoning adopted is that of the co-ordinate Bench, reproduced in full at paragraph 8. Because the assessee bought a mix of imported rough and polished diamonds from AEs and non-AEs and sold both to AEs and non-AEs, its profit and loss account reflected a mixture, and since stones are traded lot-wise it is not possible to say which polished diamond came out of which lot of rough unless a single stone is of exceptionally high carat value. Export bills showed stones of varying size, quality, colour and carat within a single bill, and below half a carat or a carat stones are not priced separately at all, so an internal CUP comparison was impossible and the TPO's insistence on CUP was misconceived and impractical. The practical difficulties faced by the industry were evidenced by the letter of the Gems and Jewellery Export Promotion Council to the CIT (Transfer Pricing), Mumbai. Rather than levy penalty, the TPO should have determined the arm's length price by comparing realisations on export sales to AEs and non-AEs for stones of similar size, quality and weight, or by calling for the AEs' profit and loss accounts and balance sheets to make an overall comparison of gross profitability, which would have revealed any diversion of profits. The Bench also noted that gross profit had risen from 7.42 per cent to 8.71 per cent and net profit from 3.9 per cent to 4.9 per cent, and that the TPO had proposed no adjustment in AY 2010-11. Although compliance was not absolute, the failure was backed by a reasonable cause and fell within s.273B.
the TPO insisted for the same and invoked Rule 10D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, and instead of determining the arms length price in respect of the international transactions of the assessee with its AEs, rather went ahead and levied penalty under Sec. 271G in the hands of the assessee.
Upload it and we will read it, work out your deadline and draft the reply. A CA reviews before anything is filed.
Handle my notice → Ask a CA on WhatsAppYes, where the failure is backed by a reasonable cause, because s.273B applies to s.271G. The Tribunal upheld the deletion of a Rs 56,72,162 penalty on a diamond trader who had furnished entity-level margins but could not split AE from non-AE segments, holding that in a trade where rough and polished diamonds move in mixed lots it is practically impossible to trace which rough stone became which polished stone, and that the assessee had substantially complied to the extent the trade allowed. This was decided by the ITAT (Mahavir Singh, Judicial Member and Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member (Mumbai Benches 'K')) and bears on section 271G, section 92D, section 92D(3), section 273B, section 92CA, section 92CA(3), section 92C(1), section Rule 10D, section Rule 10D(1) of the Income Tax Act 1961. It is reported as IT(TP)A No.2142/Mum/2017 (AY 2011-12). Section 271G is the penalty the TPO actually levies, and at 2 per cent of the value of the international transaction for EACH failure it is often larger than the adjustment. The defence here is not that the documents were unnecessary but that s.273B removes the penalty where reasonable cause is proved, and that the TPO who cannot get segmentals has other routes to the arm's length price — comparing realisations on export sales to AEs and non-AEs for stones of similar size, quality and weight, or calling for the AEs' own profit and loss accounts and balance sheets to see whether profits were diverted. The Tribunal also treated it as telling that the TPO made no adjustment at all, and that no adjustment had been proposed in the preceding year. The reasoning is written for the diamond trade but the structure travels: identify precisely why the split cannot be produced, show what you did produce, and show the alternative benchmark the TPO could have used. If it applies to you, the first step is this: Reply to the s.92D(3) requisition in writing, item by item, saying which clause of Rule 10D(1) you can meet and which you cannot, and why — a bare refusal will not attract s.273B.
For AY 2011-12 the assessee, a diamond firm operating from the Bharat Diamond Bourse, had a turnover of Rs 636.14 crores of which export sales were Rs 238.35 crores; sales to associated enterprises were Rs 28.3 crores, about 12 per cent of exports. Its transfer pricing study used TNMM with operating profit on operating cost as the profit level indicator, and compared its entity-level margin of 14.72 per cent with a comparables' margin of 9.55 per cent. Those entity-level margins combined AE and non-AE transactions. The TPO called for segmental profitability separately for the AE and non-AE segments under s.92D(3), relying on sub-clauses (d), (g) and (h) of Rule 10D(1). The assessee did not furnish the split. The TPO recorded that the details had not been filed within thirty days or at any time afterwards, that they were essential for benchmarking, that no alternative method had been offered, and that in their absence he was forced to accept the transactions as at arm's length after initiating penalty proceedings; he levied Rs 56,72,162, being 2 per cent of the AE transaction value. The CIT(A)-55, Mumbai deleted the penalty by order dated 30 November 2016. The Revenue appealed, arguing among other things that under TNMM the profit of the international transaction itself had to be furnished and that the CIT(A) had given no finding on how clauses (d), (g), (h) and (m) of Rule 10D(1) had been complied with. The matter was decided on 2018-08-02 by the ITAT (Mahavir Singh, Judicial Member and Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member (Mumbai Benches 'K')). On those facts the ITAT held as follows. The Revenue's appeal was dismissed and the deletion of the penalty upheld. Following the co-ordinate Bench in ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd. on materially identical facts, the failure to furnish AE and non-AE segmental accounts in the diamond manufacturing and trading trade was held to be backed by a reasonable cause within s.273B, the assessee having substantially complied to the extent practically possible.
The reasoning adopted is that of the co-ordinate Bench, reproduced in full at paragraph 8. Because the assessee bought a mix of imported rough and polished diamonds from AEs and non-AEs and sold both to AEs and non-AEs, its profit and loss account reflected a mixture, and since stones are traded lot-wise it is not possible to say which polished diamond came out of which lot of rough unless a single stone is of exceptionally high carat value. Export bills showed stones of varying size, quality, colour and carat within a single bill, and below half a carat or a carat stones are not priced separately at all, so an internal CUP comparison was impossible and the TPO's insistence on CUP was misconceived and impractical. The practical difficulties faced by the industry were evidenced by the letter of the Gems and Jewellery Export Promotion Council to the CIT (Transfer Pricing), Mumbai. Rather than levy penalty, the TPO should have determined the arm's length price by comparing realisations on export sales to AEs and non-AEs for stones of similar size, quality and weight, or by calling for the AEs' profit and loss accounts and balance sheets to make an overall comparison of gross profitability, which would have revealed any diversion of profits. The Bench also noted that gross profit had risen from 7.42 per cent to 8.71 per cent and net profit from 3.9 per cent to 4.9 per cent, and that the TPO had proposed no adjustment in AY 2010-11. Although compliance was not absolute, the failure was backed by a reasonable cause and fell within s.273B. In the words reproduced by the source cited on this page: "the TPO insisted for the same and invoked Rule 10D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, and instead of determining the arms length price in respect of the international transactions of the assessee with its AEs, rather went ahead and levied penalty under Sec. 271G in the hands of the assessee." The decision followed or applied ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd., ITA No. 6304/Mum/2016 (AY 2011-12), order dated 25 October 2017 — followed, paras 18 to 21 reproduced; ITO v. Nets Soft India Ltd and ACIT v. Gillette India Ltd — relied on by the CIT(A), whose order was upheld.
It was decided by the ITAT on 2018-08-02 and is reported as IT(TP)A No.2142/Mum/2017 (AY 2011-12). Binding on the AO and CIT(A) within the Tribunal's jurisdiction. Persuasive elsewhere. A Tribunal decision binds the assessing officer and the Commissioner (Appeals) within that Tribunal's jurisdiction, and is persuasive before other benches. It is not binding on a High Court, and a contrary co-ordinate bench decision will be argued against you, so check whether the point has been taken the other way before you build a reply around it. On section 271G, section 92D, section 92D(3), section 273B, section 92CA, section 92CA(3), section 92C(1), section Rule 10D, section Rule 10D(1), the practical question is whether the facts of your own notice match the facts of this case closely enough for the same rule to apply.
It helps the taxpayer. The Revenue's appeal was dismissed and the deletion of the penalty upheld. Following the co-ordinate Bench in ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd. on materially identical facts, the failure to furnish AE and non-AE segmental accounts in the diamond manufacturing and trading trade was held to be backed by a reasonable cause within s.273B, the assessee having substantially complied to the extent practically possible. It arises in Penalty and Evidence & Burden of Proof matters, on section 271G, section 92D, section 92D(3), section 273B, section 92CA, section 92CA(3), section 92C(1), section Rule 10D, section Rule 10D(1) of the Income Tax Act 1961, and was decided by Mahavir Singh, Judicial Member and Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member (Mumbai Benches 'K'). Before relying on it, read the source linked on this page and check whether it has since been distinguished, overruled or overtaken by an amendment to the Income Tax Act. In practice the steps that follow from it are these. Put the practical impossibility on record with specifics: lot-wise trading, mixed purchases from AEs and non-AEs, varying size, quality, colour and carat within a lot, a common price per carat for the whole lot. Produce the industry-level material — here the Gems and Jewellery Export Promotion Council's letter to the CIT (Transfer Pricing), Mumbai, was relied on. Offer the TPO a workable alternative benchmark in the same reply: comparison of realisations on AE and non-AE export sales for comparable stones, or the AEs' own accounts, so the record shows he had a route and did not take it. Point to the absence of any arm's length adjustment, and to acceptance in earlier years, as showing there was nothing mala fide. Plead s.273B expressly in the penalty reply; do not leave it to be inferred.
Searched for later treatment; none was found. That is not the same as a source affirming it. A citedby: search returns two later Pune Bench orders (Vedant Properties, 10 January 2025, and Zavareh Soli Poonawalla, 7 September 2026) whose snippets show a shared passage on a different subject; neither concerns s.271G or transfer-pricing documentation for a diamond trader. A second probe on both spellings of the assessee's name returns a large but unrelated result set and no decision citing this order. No Bombay High Court appeal from it was traced. The reasonable-cause reasoning under s.273B has support elsewhere in the diamond-trade s.271G line, but not through any confirmed application of this order. No source could be cited for that finding. Checking whether an authority still stands matters as much as knowing what it held: a decision may be overruled on one point and survive on another, or the provision it interprets may have been amended since. Read the source and the editor's note on this page before relying on it in a reply to an Assessing Officer or in an appeal.
The operative reasoning is not the Tribunal's own composition. Paragraph 8 of this order reproduces paragraphs 18 to 21 of the co-ordinate Bench order in ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd., ITA No. 6304/Mum/2016 (AY 2011-12), dated 25 October 2017, and paragraph 9 adopts it. The key quote is from that reproduced passage, and the penalty figure inside the reproduced passage (Rs 2,15,98,527) is the penalty in D Navinchandra, not in this case, where it was Rs 56,72,162. The assessee's name is misspelt 'Di;ipkumar' in the running header of the order. The CIT(A)'s reasoning at his paragraphs 13 and 14 is reproduced in paragraph 5 of the order. This library shows the verification state of every entry openly. This entry has not yet been read in full by a chartered accountant. The summary reflects the sources listed on this page. Read the source before you rely on it in a reply to an Assessing Officer or in an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) or the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.
The Revenue's appeal was dismissed and the deletion of the penalty upheld. Following the co-ordinate Bench in ACIT v. D Navinchandra Exports Pvt. Ltd. on materially identical facts, the failure to furnish AE and non-AE segmental accounts in the diamond manufacturing and trading trade was held to be backed by a reasonable cause within s.273B, the assessee having substantially complied to the extent practically possible.
TaxSphere, “ACIT v Dilipkumar V. Lakhi”, https://taxnotice.vittsphere.com/caselaw/case/acit-v-dilipkumar-v-lakhi-271g-diamond-segmentals/ (validity last checked 2026-09-08)
The judgment itself is a government work and may be quoted freely. The summary, the validity note and the reasoning on this page are this library's own writing: quote them with attribution, and please do not present either as the words of the court — this page keeps the two apart and so should a quotation of it.
Every entry in this library links to where it was found, so you can check it yourself rather than take our word for it.
The Transfer Pricing Officer has thrown out my working capital adjustment saying there is no prescribed method for it. Is he right that there is no prescribed method, and if he is, what does that do to the claim?
Our group is nowhere near the master file thresholds. Do we still have to file anything under Rule 10DA?
We did not file Form 3CEAA. Which penalty applies, who imposes it, and is it a percentage of anything?
The AO has levied a s.271AA penalty saying I did not maintain transfer pricing documentation, without saying which documents. Does that penalty stand?