VittSphere ONE Calculators Blog CA Firm CA Prabhakar Kumar · FCA · ICAI 560762
Case law › ITAT › ACIT v Dilipkumar V. Lakhi
ITATHelps taxpayerNo later treatment founds.271Gs.92Ds.92D(3)s.273Bs.92CAs.92CA(3)s.92C(1)Rule 10DRule 10D(1)

ACIT v Dilipkumar V. Lakhi

The TPO wants segment-wise profit and loss accounts for my AE and non-AE business and I cannot produce them. He has levied 2 per cent of the transaction value under s.271G. Can I resist it?

The Income-tax Act, 1961 was repealed on 1 April 2026. It still governs income earned up to 31 March 2026, and every proceeding about those years however late — assessment, reassessment, rectification, penalty, revision and appeal alike. Income earned from 1 April 2026 is governed by the Income-tax Act, 2025. What changed, and which Act governs your year →

The TPO wants segment-wise profit and loss accounts for my AE and non-AE business and I cannot produce them. He has levied 2 per cent of the transaction value under s.271G. Can I resist it?

Yes, where the failure is backed by a reasonable cause, because s.273B applies to s.271G. The Tribunal upheld the deletion of a Rs 56,72,162 penalty on a diamond trader who had furnished entity-level margins but could not split AE from non-AE segments, holding that in a trade where rough and polished diamonds move in mixed lots it is practically impossible to trace which rough stone became which polished stone, and that the assessee had substantially complied to the extent the trade allowed.

Decided by the ITAT (Mahavir Singh, Judicial Member and Rajesh Kumar, Accountant Member (Mumbai Benches 'K')) on 2018-08-02, reported as IT(TP)A No.2142/Mum/2017 (AY 2011-12). It bears on section 271G, section 92D, section 92D(3), section 273B, section 92CA, section 92CA(3), section 92C(1), section Rule 10D, section Rule 10D(1) of the Income Tax Act 1961, in Penalty and Evidence & Burden of Proof matters.

Searched for later treatment; none was found. That is not the same as a source affirming it. A citedby: search returns two later Pune Bench orders (Vedant Properties, 10 January 2025, and Zavareh Soli Poonawalla, 7 September 2026) whose snippets show a shared passage on a different subject; neither concerns s.271G or transfer-pricing documentation for a diamond trader. A second probe on both spellings of the assessee's name returns a large but unrelated result set and no decision citing this order. No Bombay High Court appeal from it was traced. The reasonable-cause reasoning under s.273B has support elsewhere in the diamond-trade s.271G line, but not through any confirmed application of this order.

Why it matters

Section 271G is the penalty the TPO actually levies, and at 2 per cent of the value of the international transaction for EACH failure it is often larger than the adjustment. The defence here is not that the documents were unnecessary but that s.273B removes the penalty where reasonable cause is proved, and that the TPO who cannot get segmentals has other routes to the arm's length price — comparing realisations on export sales to AEs and non-AEs for stones of similar size, quality and weight, or calling for the AEs' own profit and loss accounts and balance sheets to see whether profits were diverted. The Tribunal also treated it as telling that the TPO made no adjustment at all, and that no adjustment had been proposed in the preceding year. The reasoning is written for the diamond trade but the structure travels: identify precisely why the split cannot be produced, show what you did produce, and show the alternative benchmark the TPO could have used.

Binding on the AO and CIT(A) within the Tribunal's jurisdiction. Persuasive elsewhere.

Not yet CA-verified. This entry was found through the sources listed under the Sources tab, and the summary reflects what those sources say. Nobody has yet read the full judgment and signed it off. Check the source before relying on it.

Read aloud by your device. Press again to stop.

Related

Other authorities on the same sections.
Every authority on the provisions this decision turns on: all 61 on s.92CA · all 36 on s.273B · all 23 on s.92CA(3)

Used in these worked examples

Notice situations where this decision carries one of the steps.
Eleven comparables, an arm's length range the tested party falls below, and a draft order with thirty days on itThe Transfer Pricing Officer has built a dataset of eleven comparables and priced my captive unit at the median - what has to happen in the next thirty days, and how much of the adjustment can the exclusions actually remove?