What the courts have decided on section 92C(3), in one screen. Read this first; open an entry when you need the facts, the reasoning and the source.
-
PCIT (IT)-2 Mumbai v Gemological Institute of America Inc
High CourtHelps taxpayerNo later treatment found
An APA between your Indian company and the CBDT fixes the royalty. The officer says the second proviso to s.92C(4) still stops the foreign parent, who did not sign the APA, from being taxed on the reduced figure. Does it?
No, on this Bench's reasoning. Where an APA has been entered into between the Indian associated enterprise and the CBDT, that agreement governs the determination of the arm's length price for every year it covers, and the price falls to be determined solely on the basis of the APA. The second proviso to s.92C(4) is confined to the case where the Assessing Officer determines the arm's length price under s.92C(3); it does not reach a variation made pursuant to an APA.
-
PCIT-2 v EYGBS (India) Pvt Ltd
High CourtHelps taxpayer
Your client offered a transfer pricing adjustment itself because its APA required it. The officer says s.92C(4) bars the s.10AA exemption on that extra income. Is he right?
No. Where the assessee computes the arm's length price itself pursuant to an APA entered into with the CBDT, none of the conditions in s.92C(3) is attracted, and s.92C(4) therefore never comes into operation at all. The bar in s.92C(4) is aimed at income by which the Assessing Officer enhances the declared total income, not at figures the assessee has itself declared in conformity with its APA. The Revenue's appeals were dismissed.
-
Indorama Synthetics (India) Ltd v Additional CIT
High CourtHelps taxpayerHigh Courts differ
The Assessing Officer referred my case to the TPO in a one-paragraph letter without dealing with my objection that there was no international transaction at all. Can I attack the reference itself?
Yes. The Delhi High Court held that the Assessing Officer's satisfaction, even prima facie, that there IS an international transaction or specified domestic transaction is a sine qua non for a reference under s.92CA(1); where the assessee raises a threshold objection to jurisdiction, the officer must deal with it and must give a hearing before recording his satisfaction. The three references were set aside and the officer directed to decide afresh after hearing the assessee. The Court concurred with the Bombay High Court in Vodafone India Services and declined to follow the contrary Gujarat decision in Veer Gems, noting that CBDT Instruction No. 3 of 2016 has itself adopted the Bombay position.
-
Sony Ericsson Mobile Communications India P Ltd v CIT
High CourtCuts both waysUnder appeal
The TPO says my advertising spend is higher than comparables and has added the excess as brand building for my foreign parent. Can he do that?
Not by that route. The bright line test — treating advertising, marketing and promotion spend above a comparable's level as a separate transaction of brand building for the foreign associated enterprise — has no statutory mandate, and the parameters the Special Bench laid down in L.G. Electronics do not bind either side. The Delhi High Court set the Tribunal's approach aside as based on an erroneous legal standard and sent the matters back for fresh consideration.
Listed strongest first: Supreme Court, then High Court, then Tribunal, then CBDT. Nothing here has yet been read in full by a chartered accountant — open an entry to see where it came from.