What the courts have decided on section 43(6), in one screen. Read this first; open an entry when you need the facts, the reasoning and the source.
-
Hukumchand Mills Ltd v CIT
Supreme CourtCuts both ways
The Department raised a completely new ground before the Tribunal to support the assessment, and the Tribunal allowed it and remanded. Was the Tribunal entitled to do that?
Yes. The Supreme Court held that the Tribunal's power under section 33(4) of the 1922 Act to pass such orders as it thinks fit is expressed in the widest possible terms. The word 'thereon' confines it to the subject matter of the appeal, but within that subject matter the Tribunal may allow a ground to be raised for the first time and may direct a further enquiry. The subject matter here was the written down value of the assessee's buildings and machinery, and it was open to the Department to support the finding on that on any ground decided against it. The Appellate Tribunal Rules are procedural and do not cut down the section.
-
CIT v Oswal Agro Mills Ltd — depreciation on a block of assets cannot be split asset by asset for non-user
High CourtHelps taxpayer
One of my units has been shut for years. The Assessing Officer has pulled the assets of that unit out of the block and disallowed the depreciation on them. Can he?
No. The Delhi High Court held that after the 1988 amendment depreciation is allowed on the written down value of the block of assets, individual assets have lost their identity, and the Revenue cannot segregate a particular asset from the block on the ground that it was not put to use. The Revenue's appeals were dismissed even though the unit concerned had been closed for years.
-
CIT v Bharat Aluminium
High CourtHelps taxpayer
One machine in my block of assets was not used this year. Can the AO deny depreciation on it?
No. Once assets are clubbed into a block they lose their individual identity and become an inseparable part of the block, so 'used for the purpose of business' means use of the block and not of any specific item. User of an individual asset is required only in the first year in which that asset is acquired.
-
Nirma Ltd v DCIT — depreciation on goodwill from amalgamation, and the date the Finance Act 2021 closed it
ITATHelps taxpayerSuperseded by amendment
The Assessing Officer has disallowed depreciation on goodwill that arose when a company amalgamated into mine. Which years can I still claim it for?
Only assessment years up to AY 2020-21. The Finance Act 2021 removed goodwill of a business or profession from the definition of block of assets in s.2(11) and from s.32, excluded it from Explanation 3(b) to s.32(1), and amended s.43(6)(c)(ii) to require the written down value of goodwill to be reduced from the opening WDV where goodwill already formed part of a block; those amendments apply prospectively from AY 2021-22. For earlier years the Tribunal here allowed the claim on Smifs Securities, and the amendment gives the Assessing Officer no ground to disturb it.
-
Statutory position — Rule 11UAE and the substituted s.50B(2) and s.2(42C): slump sale from AY 2021-22
CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
My client is signing a business transfer agreement now. Can I still take the price in the agreement as the full value of consideration for the s.50B computation, the way every reported case does?
No. From AY 2021-22 s.50B(2)(ii) deems the fair market value of the capital assets on the date of transfer, calculated in the prescribed manner, to be the full value of the consideration, and Rule 11UAE prescribes that manner: the fair market value is the higher of FMV1, an asset-based value of the undertaking, and FMV2, the fair market value of the consideration actually received. The agreed price is now a floor, not the measure. The same Finance Act also widened s.2(42C) to a transfer 'by any means', so an exchange or a scheme is caught.
-
Statutory position — the second proviso to s.32(1): where an asset is acquired during the previous year AND put to use for less than 180 days in that year, depreciation is restricted to fifty per cent — the exact words, what the 180 days is counted on, and the further proviso giving the balance of the additional allowance in the succeeding year
CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
We bought plant in February and used it from March. The Assessing Officer has halved the depreciation. Is the 180 days counted from acquisition or from the date the asset was put to use, and what happens to the other half of the additional depreciation under s.32(1)(iia)?
The proviso is worded on BOTH events, and that is the whole fight. As printed on the most recent departmental edition, it reads: "Provided further that where an asset referred to in clause (i) or clause (ii) or clause (iia) or the first proviso to clause (iia), as the case may be, is acquired by the assessee during the previous year and is put to use for the purposes of business or profession for a period of less than one hundred and eighty days in that previous year, the deduction under this sub-section in respect of such asset shall be restricted to fifty per cent of the amount calculated at the percentage prescribed for an asset under clause (i) or clause (ii) or clause (iia), as the case may be :". So the restriction applies only where TWO things are true of the same previous year — the asset was acquired by the assessee during that previous year, and it was put to use for the purposes of business or profession for a period of less than 180 days in that previous year. The 180-day count is on the period of USE ("is put to use ... for a period of less than one hundred and eighty days"); acquisition during the previous year is a separate, cumulative condition, not the thing counted. An asset acquired in an earlier previous year is outside the proviso even if it is used for less than 180 days in the year in question. The further proviso, printed immediately after, gives back the missing half of the ADDITIONAL depreciation only: where an asset referred to in clause (iia) or the first proviso to clause (iia) is acquired during the previous year and put to use for less than 180 days in that year and the deduction is accordingly restricted to fifty per cent, "then, the deduction for the balance fifty per cent of the amount calculated at the percentage prescribed for such asset under clause (iia) shall be allowed under this sub-section in the immediately succeeding previous year in respect of such asset". The footnote evidence I could read attaches that further proviso to an insertion effective 1 April 2016; the Act number as the departmental page prints it is set out in the editor note and I could not reconcile it.
Listed strongest first: Supreme Court, then High Court, then Tribunal, then CBDT. Nothing here has yet been read in full by a chartered accountant — open an entry to see where it came from.