CIT v DLF Commercial Developers Ltd
High CourtHelps department
My company lost money trading in exchange traded derivatives. Section 43(5)(d) says those are not speculative transactions, so can I set the loss off against ordinary business income?
No, not if the Explanation to section 73 applies to the company. The Delhi High Court held that the exclusion of eligible derivative transactions from "speculative transaction" in section 43(5)(d) is confined to the provisions for which that definition was enacted, and does not carry into the Explanation to section 73. Derivatives take their value from the underlying stocks and shares, and if the share business itself is deemed speculative under the Explanation, so is the derivative business built on it. The Tribunal's order allowing carry forward of the Rs.4.92 crore loss was set aside and the Revenue's appeal allowed.
Statutory position — s.43(5): what a speculative transaction is, and the five clauses of the proviso that take a transaction out of it — raw-material hedging, stocks-and-shares hedging, jobbing and arbitrage by a member, eligible derivative transactions on a recognised stock exchange, and commodity derivatives — with the effective date of each
CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
The Assessing Officer says our loss is a speculation loss under s.43(5) and cannot be set off. We settled the contracts without taking delivery, but they were hedges against our own raw-material purchases — and separately we trade exchange derivatives. Which of the proviso clauses do I get, and from which year?
Settlement without delivery is what makes a transaction speculative, and the proviso then takes five described kinds of transaction back out. The definition, as printed on the departmental Year 2021 edition, is that "speculative transaction" means a transaction in which a contract for the purchase or sale of any commodity, including stocks and shares, is periodically or ultimately settled otherwise than by the actual delivery or transfer of the commodity or scrips. The proviso then provides that, for the purposes of the clause, (a) a contract in respect of raw materials or merchandise entered into by a person in the course of his manufacturing or merchanting business to guard against loss through future price fluctuations in respect of his contracts for actual delivery of goods manufactured by him or merchandise sold by him; or (b) a contract in respect of stocks and shares entered into by a dealer or investor therein to guard against loss in his holdings of stocks and shares through price fluctuations; or (c) a contract entered into by a member of a forward market or a stock exchange in the course of any transaction in the nature of jobbing or arbitrage to guard against loss which may arise in the ordinary course of his business as such member; or (d) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in derivatives referred to in clause (ac) of section 2 of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (42 of 1956) carried out in a recognised stock exchange; or (e) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in commodity derivatives carried out in a recognised stock exchange, which is chargeable to commodities transaction tax under Chapter VII of the Finance Act, 2013 (17 of 2013), shall not be deemed to be a speculative transaction. DATES, from the footnotes. Clauses (a), (b) and (c) are the original limbs and are printed on the departmental Year 1985 edition. Clause (d) was inserted by the Finance Act, 2005 with effect from 1 April 2006, with "(ac)" substituted for "(aa)" by the Finance Act, 2006 with effect from 1 April 2006. Clause (e) was inserted by the Finance Act, 2013 with effect from 1 April 2014, and originally read "carried out in a recognised association"; the words "recognised stock exchange" were substituted for "recognised association" by Act No. 12 of 2020 with effect from 1 April 2020. A second proviso now provides that for the purposes of clause (e) of the first proviso, in respect of trading in agricultural commodity derivatives, the requirement of chargeability of commodity transaction tax under Chapter VII of the Finance Act, 2013 shall not apply; it is absent from the Year 2014 edition and present on the Year 2021 edition, and the departmental copy of the Finance Bill, 2018 carries it at clause 12 to take effect from 1 April 2019 — I did NOT read the Finance Act, 2018 as enacted and say so.