What the courts have decided on section 132(4A), in one screen. Read this first; open an entry when you need the facts, the reasoning and the source.
-
P.R. Metrani v CIT
Supreme CourtHelps taxpayerSuperseded by amendment
Can papers seized in a search be presumed true against me in the regular assessment?
That was not the law as this case decided it: the s.132(4A) presumption operated only within the search proceedings and not in a regular assessment under s.143. Parliament changed that by inserting s.292C in 2007. What survives from this judgment is that the presumption is rebuttable and that seized documents can still be used as ordinary evidence even without it.
-
Prem Dass v ITO
Supreme CourtHelps taxpayer
The Tribunal cancelled my concealment penalty, but the prosecution under section 276C is still running. Does the penalty finding help me in the criminal court?
Yes. The Supreme Court set aside the conviction and acquitted the appellant. Section 276C needs a wilful attempt to evade, which is a positive act that must be proved, and section 277 needs mens rea - that the person knew or believed the verification to be false, or did not believe it true. Neither can be made out from the presumption in section 132(4A) about seized books. The Court also held that the Tribunal's finding that this was a difference of opinion on estimates, not concealment, and the reduction of the penalty, could not be lost sight of, given the legislative intent in section 279(1A).
-
Commissioner of Income Tax v Girish Chaudhary
High CourtHelps taxpayer
A loose sheet seized in the search has bare figures on it and the officer has read '48' as Rs 48 lakhs of undisclosed income. Can that stand without anything more?
No. The Delhi High Court upheld the deletion of the Rs 48 lakh addition. There was no material on record to show on what basis the officer concluded that the figure 48 was to be read as Rs 48 lakhs. Following the Supreme Court in CBI v V.C. Shukla, a file of loose sheets is not a book of account, so entries in it are not admissible under section 34 of the Evidence Act, 1872, and the seized annexure was a dumb document leading nowhere. The Court endorsed the Tribunal's view that it was for the Revenue to put life into the document by collecting other relevant and connected material, which it had not done. The appeal was dismissed.
-
Manoj Kumar Jagetia v ITO
ITATHelps taxpayerNo later treatment found
My s.80GGC donation has been disallowed and the same money added back under s.69A, purely because the Investigation Wing says the party ran a cash-back racket. Nothing in the order names me. Can that stand?
No. A general modus operandi found in a search of the recipient political party may justify opening an enquiry, but it cannot by itself prove that this donor got his money back; the Revenue must produce assessee-specific material and must confront the donor with it. The Tribunal restored the full Rs.3,00,000 deduction under s.80GGC and deleted the consequential Rs.2,85,000 addition under s.69A.
-
Kimaya Buildtech LLP v DCIT
ITATHelps taxpayerNo later treatment found
The addition against me rests on a WhatsApp chat found on someone else's phone in his search, and on his statement under s.132(4). Does the presumption in s.132(4A) and s.292C apply to me?
No. The presumption runs against the person from whose possession or control the material was found, not against a third party named in it. Without corroborative material the assessee is not even required to explain the contents, and the Rs 4 crore on-money addition was deleted.
-
T.S. Kumarasamy v Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax
ITATCuts both ways
In my block assessment the officer said my seized books were unreliable, and then taxed the loan entries in those same books as undisclosed income. Can he have it both ways?
No. The Chennai Bench deleted the addition of Rs 1.68 crores. An officer who doubts the veracity of the accounts cannot at the same time rely on entries in them to make an addition; that is blowing hot and cold in the same breath. Section 132(4A) requires the contents of books found in a search to be presumed true, so it is not open to the officer to say the loan entries are false, and loans recorded in the books are not undisclosed income within section 158B(b). The estimate that half the remaining creditors were bogus, drawn from an enquiry with four out of 43 whose report was never put to the assessee, was arbitrary. The Rs 50 lakhs admitted on oath, however, could not be retracted.
Listed strongest first: Supreme Court, then High Court, then Tribunal, then CBDT. Nothing here has yet been read in full by a chartered accountant — open an entry to see where it came from.