Section 115F

Section 115F — the law in short

What the courts have decided on section 115F, in one screen. Read this first; open an entry when you need the facts, the reasoning and the source.

• Deivanayagam Maruthini v. DDIT (International Taxation), Chennai (ITAT Chennai) — bonus shares issued on original shares subscribed to in convertible foreign exchange are themselves a 'foreign exchange asset', so the s.115E concessional rate applies to the gain on selling them ITATHelps taxpayerValidity unconfirmed
  My NRI client subscribed to shares of an Indian company in convertible foreign exchange, later received bonus shares on them, and has now sold only the bonus shares. The assessing officer says bonus shares were not acquired with foreign exchange, so they are not a foreign exchange asset and the concessional rate under section 115E is not available. Is he right?
  No, on this Tribunal's reasoning. It held that there can be no differentiation between the definition of 'foreign exchange asset' as applied to section 115E and as applied to section 115F, and that bonus shares issued on original shares acquired in convertible foreign exchange are covered by section 115C(b) — so the long-term capital gain on selling the bonus shares takes the concessional rate under section 115E. The orders of the lower authorities were set aside and the Assessing Officer was directed to give the assessees the benefit of the concessional rate.
• Smt. Trishla Jain v. Dy. CIT (ITAT Delhi) — short-term capital gains derived from a foreign exchange asset fall within 'investment income' in s.115C(c) and take the concessional rate, notwithstanding that s.115E names only long-term capital gains ITATHelps taxpayerValidity unconfirmed
  My NRI client bought equity shares of an Indian company in convertible foreign exchange and sold them within a year. The assessing officer says section 115E mentions only long-term capital gains, so the short-term gain goes at ordinary rates. Is there any authority the other way?
  Yes. The Tribunal held that a short-term capital gain derived from a foreign exchange asset is income derived from that asset and therefore falls within the definition of 'investment income' in section 115C(c), so the assessee is entitled to the concessional rate under section 115E. It rejected the Revenue's argument that the express mention of long-term capital gains in section 115E excludes short-term gains by necessary implication.
• Statutory position — s.115E: twenty per cent on investment income throughout, and long-term capital gains at ten per cent before 23 July 2024 and twelve and one-half per cent on or after it CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
  My NRI client sold shares of an Indian company that he had subscribed to in foreign exchange. The transfer was in September 2024. My software has computed the tax at ten per cent under section 115E. Which rate applies, and from when did it change?
  Twelve and one-half per cent, because the transfer took place on or after 23 July 2024. Section 115E(ii) now splits the long-term capital gains rate — ten per cent for any transfer which takes place before the 23rd day of July, 2024, and twelve and one-half per cent for any transfer on or after that date — while the rate on investment income under s.115E(i) remains twenty per cent and has done since 1 April 1998.
• Statutory position — s.115C: the Chapter XII-A definitions, and the convertible-foreign-exchange condition that the whole chapter turns on CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
  My client is a person of Indian origin living in Dubai. He bought shares in an Indian listed company out of rupees lying in his NRO account. The assessing officer says Chapter XII-A does not apply to him at all and has taxed the gain at the ordinary rate. Is he right?
  On these facts, yes — and the reason is the funding, not the status. Section 115C(b) defines a "foreign exchange asset" as any specified asset "which the assessee has acquired or purchased with, or subscribed to in, convertible foreign exchange", so an asset bought out of rupee funds is not a foreign exchange asset, and nothing in Chapter XII-A — not s.115E, not s.115F, not s.115H — can reach it. Being a non-resident Indian within s.115C(e) is a necessary condition but never a sufficient one.
• Statutory position — s.115-I: the non-resident Indian's annual election OUT of Chapter XII-A, made in the return itself CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
  Chapter XII-A gives my NRI client a flat twenty per cent with no deductions, but on his numbers the ordinary slab rates with Chapter VI-A relief come out cheaper. Can he simply not use the chapter, and does he have to commit for good?
  He can, and the election is for one assessment year at a time. Section 115-I lets a non-resident Indian elect not to be governed by Chapter XII-A for any assessment year by furnishing his return for that year under section 139 and DECLARING THEREIN that the chapter shall not apply to him for that year; if he does so, his total income for that year is computed and taxed in accordance with the other provisions of the Act.
• Statutory position — s.115F: the six-month rollover of net consideration into a specified asset, the proportionate formula where only part is reinvested, and the three-year lock-in CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
  My NRI client sold debentures of an Indian public company that he had subscribed to in foreign exchange, and put most but not all of the money into fresh shares of an Indian company within four months. How much of the gain escapes tax, and what happens if he sells the new shares in two years' time?
  The exempt part is the same proportion of the capital gain as the cost of the new asset bears to the NET CONSIDERATION — not to the gain — so a partial reinvestment shelters a strictly proportionate slice. If he transfers or converts the new asset into money within three years of acquiring it, the amount not charged under section 45 is deemed to be his long-term capital gains of the previous year in which that happens.
• Statutory position — s.115H: continuation of the Chapter XII-A benefit after the assessee becomes resident, and the two things it does not cover CBDT Circulars & InstructionsCuts both ways
  My client has returned to India for good and is now assessable as a resident. He holds shares and public-company debentures bought in foreign exchange while he was abroad. Can he keep the twenty per cent rate, and on what?
  He can, but only on part of it, and only if he files the declaration on time. Section 115H lets a person who was a non-resident Indian in a previous year and becomes assessable as resident in a subsequent year furnish a declaration in writing ALONG WITH his return under section 139 for that assessment year, and the chapter then continues to apply to him until the asset is transferred or converted into money — but the continuation extends only to INVESTMENT INCOME, and only from assets of the nature in sub-clauses (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of section 115C(f). Shares in an Indian company, which are sub-clause (i), are not in the list.

Listed strongest first: Supreme Court, then High Court, then Tribunal, then CBDT. Nothing here has yet been read in full by a chartered accountant — open an entry to see where it came from.