VittSphere ONE Calculators Blog CA Firm CA Prabhakar Kumar · FCA · ICAI 560762
Case law › ITAT › DCIT v Smt. Ashu Ashok
ITATHelps taxpayerNo later treatment founds.44AD

DCIT v Smt. Ashu Ashok

I declared more than 8 per cent under s.44AD. The officer has disallowed my expenditure for want of vouchers and allowed only 30 per cent on estimate. Can he do that?

The Income-tax Act, 1961 was repealed on 1 April 2026. It still governs income earned up to 31 March 2026, and every proceeding about those years however late — assessment, reassessment, rectification, penalty, revision and appeal alike. Income earned from 1 April 2026 is governed by the Income-tax Act, 2025. What changed, and which Act governs your year →

I declared more than 8 per cent under s.44AD. The officer has disallowed my expenditure for want of vouchers and allowed only 30 per cent on estimate. Can he do that?

No. Where the case falls under s.44AD and the assessee has declared income above the prescribed rate of 8 per cent of gross receipts, she is not required to maintain books or documents to justify the expenditure, and estimating expenses and recomputing income is not within the Assessing Officer's domain. The Revenue's appeal against deletion of the addition was dismissed.

Decided by the ITAT (Sudhir Kumar, Judicial Member and Manish Agarwal, Accountant Member) on 2026-05-08, reported as ITA No. 3898/Del/2023; Assessment Year 2017-18; Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench 'A'; date of hearing 27 April 2026. It bears on section 44AD of the Income Tax Act 1961, in Presumptive Taxation & Audit, Assessment & Scrutiny and Search, Survey & Block Assessment matters.

Searched for later treatment; none was found. That is not the same as a source affirming it. The citator search (doc 21869090, confirmed as 'DCIT, Income Tax Department vs Smt. Ashu Ashok, Delhi on 8 May, 2026') returns nothing. A second probe on the assessee's name returned fifteen results, of which the High Court matters are criminal proceedings involving other people of a similar name, and the only other tax item is an earlier ITAT Delhi order of 11 February 2026 in this assessee's case, which pre-dates this one. The holding that the Assessing Officer cannot re-estimate expenses against a s.44AD return has attracted no later treatment. Nothing overruling, doubting or distinguishing it was found, and no appeal to a High Court against it is disclosed on the record searched.

Why it matters

This answers the commonest way an officer attacks a presumptive return: he accepts that s.44AD applies but then asks for vouchers for the expenditure, disallows what is unvouched, and substitutes his own estimate of a permissible expense ratio — here 30 per cent of gross receipts. The Tribunal's answer is that the exercise is jurisdictionally misconceived, because s.44AD(2) deems the deductions under sections 30 to 38 already given full effect to, so there is no expenditure left for the officer to examine. The point is worth more than the usual 'no books required' argument, because it works even where the officer is not disputing the turnover: the officer's difficulty is not evidential but one of authority. Two limits. First, it depends on the declared income actually exceeding 8 per cent of gross receipts; the Tribunal's sentence is expressly conditioned on that. From AY 2017-18 the proviso reduces the rate to 6 per cent for receipts through banking channels, so the comparison must be made against the rate applicable to the mix of receipts, not against 8 per cent in every case. Second, it says nothing about a receipt that never entered the declared turnover — the same order sustains the deletion of a separate jewellery addition on wholly different reasoning, and the Rs 8,16,000 bank credit that the Assessing Officer treated as an unexplained cash credit was not before the Tribunal. Compare Calories Count v DCIT, where the Tribunal did allow the officer to go behind the declared turnover itself on impounded material; the two orders together mark out the line — the turnover is open to challenge on evidence, the expenditure underneath the presumptive rate is not.

Binding on the AO and CIT(A) within the Tribunal's jurisdiction. Persuasive elsewhere.

Not yet CA-verified. This entry was found through the sources listed under the Sources tab, and the summary reflects what those sources say. Nobody has yet read the full judgment and signed it off. Check the source before relying on it.

Read aloud by your device. Press again to stop.

Related

Other authorities on the same sections.
Every authority on the provisions this decision turns on: all 34 on s.44AD

Used in these worked examples

Notice situations where this decision carries one of the steps.
A s.139(9) notice on a turnover difference between Form 3CD and the return, answered eight months after the fifteen days ran outThe processing centre called my return defective, the fifteen days have gone and the portal now shows the return as invalid - is the loss carry-forward and the deduction gone, and what do I do first?